Which Mattress Toppers Are Best?

A layer of cushioning can make your bed more comfortable and also relieve pressure on the joints. Which mattress covers work best?

Dr. Holliday-Bell recommends this organic option for those who need the supple support of memory foam but want to stay clear of chemicals. It has an easily removable cover and provides a range of firmness levels that will suit the majority of sleepers.

1. Sleep Innovations Gel Memory Topper

This topper is soft enough for the majority of people to enjoy, but it doesn’t sacrifice support. It was shaped to fit the contours of our testers’ bodies and offered support in all the right areas. It fits all mattresses, but it can be difficult to put the sheets on. (Read more about how to set up mattress toppers here). The extra thick mattress topper memory foam layer is machine washable and naturally anti-bacterial. It also comes with a quilted cover made from bamboo that is sustainable and sourced from sustainable sources. It is also hypoallergenic. It was a popular choice of our panelists, however it’s important to remember that it does not have straps that help anchor the top of your bed as it can shift as you sleep.

The panelists who liked this topper also appreciated how it eased back pain. It’s also a great choice for heavier sleepers, who might find that a larger topper like this one –three to four inches – provides more relief from pressure points in sensitive areas like shoulders and hips.

A two-inch layer of memory foam infused with copper wicks heat and promotes airflow for a cool and refreshing night’s sleep. Our test subject Jaclyn found the topper adequate in its firmness to ease pressure on her back, front, and side sleeping positions, but not too firm that it felt uncomfortable. She also noticed that the back pain “pretty quickly disappeared overnight.” She was also amazed by the quietness of the topper, even when it’s coupled with spring mattresses. It also stops motion transfer, which makes it a good option for couples sharing a bed.

2. Coop Home Goods Retreat

We love the plush pillow feel of Coop Home Goods’ mattress toppers and when this spot-clean only version came up in our research we knew that it had to be part of. It’s made of the brand’s crosscut memory foam and microfiber blend that’s hypoallergenic, and ideal for anyone looking to upgrade the mattress they have or re-energize the bed in a dorm or guest room rental home. What makes this topper especially distinctive is the inclusion of five body-zones that have different density zones, which allows it to be shaped and molded to your body’s unique shape and still provide sufficient support.

The cover of this topper is made from 100 percent microfiber that is brushed and it features the baffle box structure that creates pockets of fill to keep it evenly distributed. It also features four elastic straps at each corner to help keep the topper firmly placed on your mattress. The copper-infused memory absorbs heat from your body, keeping you cool during the night. It’s finished off with a 2″ layer ventilated memory for more airflow.

The Retreat is the most suitable mattress topper for those who prefer a soft feel. When Strategist writer Louise tried it, she noted that the topper quickly adjusted to her body and hugged her so she felt well-supported and comfortable. She is prone to overheating in bed however the Retreat stayed her cool and didn’t move significantly throughout the night. It comes in two firmness options and back, side and stomach sleepers will be able to find it fits their preferences.

3. Nolah Beds Luxury Firm Memory Foam Topper

If you’re in the market for a mattress topper There are plenty of options to choose from. Some are designed to help you stay cool or regulate your temperature, while others provide a little more support or comfort. A mattress topper is a great way to upgrade your mattress without spending much money. A memory foam mattress is a good option for most sleepers, but should you prefer the bouncy feel of an innerspring mattress topper for caravan bed look into a hybrid topper that blends latex with tiny nano-springs.

For back and side sleepers, a firmer topper will better align your spine and ease pressure on areas that are sensitive. Our test subject Julia was impressed with this four-inch topper by Tempur that is manufactured in the US and comes with an impressive 120-night trial. She was delighted with the added comfort and quality of sleep it provided. There was an off-gassing smell when she first opened the mattress, but this went away after the next day.

This firm version from Parachute offers shredded memory foam that’s not as dense, but feels comfortable. Strategist contributor Lauren Levy says that it’s “much cheaper than a down topper” and provides similar marshmallow softness and baffle-box construction. She liked sleeping on it, but doesn’t recommend for front sleepers because her torso was smashed in the top.

A topper made from natural wool fleece is hypoallergenic and soft. However, it’s not as permeable as memory foam, and can make you feel warm in the night. Cotton is a good choice, as it is air-conditioned and keeps you cool. Some topper fabrics are infused with graphite, copper and gel infusions to help you stay cool.

4. Sleep Innovations Gel Cooling Memory foam topper

This topper from Puffy is a great budget choice, offering a soft feeling and gentle pressure-relieving support for a low price. It comes in a variety different density and thickness options to help you find the perfect mattress.

Strategist contributing writer Lauren Levy loved that this topper is similar to down — it’s “marshmallow soft” and features an affle-box design with a pillow-like fiber-fill. It’s hypoallergenic and comes with an easy-to-clean cover that helps you maintain the cleanliness in your mattress.

The topper’s 2″ layer of copper-infused memory foam promotes airflow and wicks moisture throughout the night, allowing you to remain cool. Although it doesn’t have the same bounce as latex toppers, Levy found it to be very comfortable. It’s ideal for people who sleep on their backs, sides, or stomachs, and also for those who suffer from chronic pain.

Standard features include a 10-year warranty as well as free shipping and an extended warranty of 10 years. This topper can be cleaned easily by spot-cleaning it and letting it air dry. You should not put it in a washer or dryer as this will void the warranty.

The Sleep Innovations Gel Cooling Memory Foam Topper provides a fantastic budget-friendly option for a comfortable, soft mattress. It is medium (5) firm and is suitable for most sleepers. However, those who find their small double mattress topper too firm can benefit from this mattress. It also stops transfer of movement which is vital for combination sleepers. And, like the Coop Home Goods Retreat topper, it offers relief from pressure for neck and shoulder pain. This topper comes with one drawback that it might not breathe as well as latex or foam which is why it’s not the best choice for sleepers who are hot.

5. Nolah Beds Luxury Plush Memory Foam Topper

The Nolah Beds Luxury Plush Memory Foam Topper offers a great option for side sleepers and back sleepers who want to soften the firmness of their mattress. This topper also helps reduce pressure points, making it a good option for those suffering from chronic pain. It is made in the USA from non-toxic materials, and it’s a great choice for those who sleep hot. It features a 2″ layer that is cleverly infused with copper foam that helps in promoting ventilation while also providing support. It also comes with an organic cotton cover that offers optimal moisture management. Our tester Paige discovered that this topper did a good job at stopping motion transfer and providing substantial softness, without sacrificing support. However, she noticed that the edges didn’t completely cover her mattress If support for the edges is important to you, this might not be the best mattress for you.

The topper is also easy to clean as it has a washable, removable cover. It’s also hypoallergenic as well as antibacterial, which ensures a healthy sleep. It also features five body zones that help various parts of the mattress. It also comes with a lifetime warranty and a sleep trial of 120 nights which is a lot longer than the policies of competitors.

This is one of our cheapest alternatives, but it does not sacrifice quality. It’s made with a blend of memory foam and latex that adds an exquisitely soft feel to any mattress. It has a thicker memory foam layer that provides extra firm mattress topper comfort and promote restful sleep. While it may not be the ideal choice for stomach sleepers because it tends to sink in too much and could cause spinal misalignment, it’s a solid option for those who are seeking better sleep for less.